LED instrument lights

[Razorburns]

Ran into a bit of a question here:

I replaced the both bulbs in the speedo with blue LEDs..... they look super sweet and is a bit brighter to boot. Picked up a replacement turn signal relay to accommodate LED turn signal bulbs, and put that in.

Moved onto replacing the neutral and the turn signal indicator lights with blue LEDs. The neutral indicator lit right up and is awesome. Quite a bit brighter and really slick looking. The turn signal one though only lights up to indicate one side (while the signals themselves light up just fine). I pulled out the bulb, switched it around, and the OTHER side is indicated (again, the signals themselves are working fine).

Am I missing something here? The contacts on the LED indicator bulbs look exactly the same as the OEM bulbs, so I'm not sure what is going on. Put the OEM bulb back in. I'll come back to it another time.

Can post photos of things lit up blue if people want.