'02 Vulcan 500

[Easy Rider]

Originally Posted by BillInGA

Here's what the tailpipe looks like with the backplate on:

Going through postimg, they come out too small to see any detail.
You might want to give it another go by posting them directly on here.

Looks to me like the backplate itself is pretty much intact and they have punched or otherwise screwed up the baffles inside. A replacement might be your only good option.